Palm Beach
Book Reviews

The Calamity Club

Sarah Kathryn Stockett waited seventeen years to publish a second novel, which places a rather unforgiving burden on The Calamity Club before its characters have even entered the room.

The Calamity Club

Sarah Kathryn Stockett waited seventeen years to publish a second novel, which places a rather unforgiving burden on The Calamity Club before its characters have even entered the room. Fortunately, Stockett returns to Mississippi with the qualities that made The Help so readable: an ear for Southern speech, a sharp eye for social hypocrisy and an abiding interest in women whom respectable society has badly underestimated.

The story opens in Oxford, Mississippi, in 1933, when the Depression has stripped away any polite fiction that security is distributed according to merit. Eleven-year-old Meg Lefleur has spent two years at the Lafayette County Orphan Asylum after her mother left her there on Christmas Eve. Classified among the older girls whom prospective parents are unlikely to choose, Meg protects herself with intelligence, suspicion and a refusal to believe she has been permanently abandoned. She is funny without becoming precocious for the convenience of the reader, and her determination gives the sprawling novel its strongest pulse.

Birdie Calhoun arrives in Oxford carrying a different variety of desperation. Unmarried, outspoken and skilled with numbers, she hopes her socially successful sister Frances will help the family Birdie has been supporting. Frances has acquired a wealthy husband and a carefully arranged life, but the household proves far less secure than its polished exterior suggests. Birdie’s bookkeeping eventually brings her into the affairs of the orphanage and into Meg’s orbit, where ledgers reveal that institutions can conceal cruelty as efficiently as families conceal debt.

Charlie, a resourceful woman with few remaining options, completes the novel’s central alliance. Her proposed solution to their problems is audacious, morally complicated and entertaining enough that readers may find themselves supporting conduct they would firmly condemn at a neighborhood association meeting. Stockett allows the women to be generous, exasperating, frightened and opportunistic, sometimes within the same conversation. Their friendship is not sentimental decoration; it is the practical arrangement that makes survival possible when every official system has failed them.

Beneath the adventure lies a disturbing account of how poor and unconventional women were judged by authorities empowered to decide who was fit to become a mother. Stockett incorporates the era’s eugenics movement and forced sterilization policies without turning the novel into a history lecture. The facts are horrifying precisely because they enter through the lives of characters readers have come to know, including girls who understand that being labeled troublesome can have consequences far beyond an afternoon in the matron’s office.

At more than 650 pages, The Calamity Club occasionally carries one complication too many, and its final convergence requires several pieces to fall into place with suspicious efficiency. Stockett’s characters, however, are strong enough to pull the machinery along. Meg provides the courage, Birdie the moral argument and Charlie the nerve, while the women surrounding them form a community built from necessity rather than social approval.

The Calamity Club is historical fiction with a generous appetite for plot, humor and righteous troublemaking. It acknowledges that desperation does not always produce noble decisions and that respectable people are often protected from the consequences of far worse ones. Stockett has written a substantial, spirited novel about women denied conventional power who become remarkably inventive once they stop waiting for permission.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Keep reading

More Book Reviews

Welcome back

An account puts your game results on the 33480 leaderboard. All it takes is a username and a password.

3 to 20 letters, numbers, dots or underscores; this is the name the leaderboard shows. Passwords need 8 or more characters. There’s no email on file, so keep your password somewhere safe.